
John Kerry and Vietnam: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly
It has been surprising to me that Senator Kerry made Vietnam the centerpiece of his campaign. It was over 30 years ago, and he made his fame as an anti-war activist. I suppose that the reason for this was to contrast his Vietnam era service with President Bush's as a proxy for the war on terror. A decorated combat veteran vice an Air Guardsman who had a spotty record of attendance - the records would then transfer to this war in a favorable way for Kerry.
But the American electorate have proven time and again that they don't really care about military service in their elected officials. For example, President Bush, a decorated torpedo bomber pilot in WWII was defeated by Bill Clinton, who famously had avoided service without even bothering with serving in the National Guard. President Clinton then went on to defeat Bob Dole, a decorated combat veteran of WWII. George W. Bush defeated John McCain, a decorated Vietnam POW, and then went on to defeat (don't start!) Al Gore, who did serve in Vietnam.
The made up controversy over George W. Bush's Guard service is spent, and has been over and done for a while. So again, surprising that Kerry would try to make that the centerpiece.
But he has, and it has an effect on the election - good, bad, and ugly.
The Good
John Kerry has rehabilitated Vietnam. The official stance of the Democrat Party now is support of Vietnam Veterans. Kerry spoke more - much more - of his 4 months of service in Vietnam than of his years as an anti-war activist. Either he believes that the service is more admirable than the opposition, or he recognizes that the public values the service more than the opposition. Either way, it is a significant change for the Democrat Party from even earlier this year. In his acceptance speech, Kerry said this: "I defended this country as a young man..." He described his service in Vietnam as defending the country. That's a good thing.
The Bad
Kerry has made Vietnam not only his centerpiece, but his defensive shield. It is kind of a joke that he is constantly invoking Vietnam as his answer for every issue, but the joke came from the truth. By couching an issue in Vietnam, he places it off limits. Noone can question Vietnam, or anyone who served there. John McCain has joined him in this position.
The Ugly
And so we come to the Swift Boat Veterans. The situation is ugly. I don't think there is any profit in going back to 35 year old medals awarded and saying "he shouldn't have gotten them." President Bush received an honorable discharge from the Air National Guard, that should settle the issue. The Navy awarded the medals to Kerry, that should settle the issue.
The Swift Boat Veterans are suddenly exempt from the no Vietnam veteran can be questioned zone of protection. A bit of ugliness will no doubt visit upon them soon.
But what could be really ugly is that the main point right now is not that John Kerry did not do some heroic things - it is quite clear that he did, Jim Rassman is not mistaken about that. The main point right now is something that Kerry has claimed numerous times, and that is having been in Cambodia in his Swift boat Christmas of 1968. The Swift Boat Veterans say this is untrue. The results of this conflict will be ugly, indeed.
posted by blaster at 01:49 AM | Comments (1)
|