 |
 |

Wherein Edward Mendelson learns about blogs
Instapundit links to a story in PCMagazine where a guy named Edward Mendelson puts up a story purporting to show that the IBM Composer and MS Word are practically indistinguishable. (He writes: "I performed this experiment in typography because I have been interested for years in the history and technology of type, not for any partisan political purposes, except to the degree that the public interest is better served by truth than by falsehoods" - i.e., he's not political, he's just for the truth.)
Anyway, he puts up a piece of a scan from the Composer manual that he got from the internet, then does a Word document of the same text, and lays them next to each other and says, see, you can't tell the difference. Instapundit notes in his post that the images are small, so it is hard to see. Well, they are small, but they are still easy to compare. And we are all empowered to do the exact same thing that Mendelson did. So I fired up Word and started typing. First thing I noticed, while Mendelson writes that he did this "without any adjustments whatsoever to the spacing of the type," he did have to make a couple of adjustments to Word out of the box - he had to turn on full justification and he had to adjust his margin to 3 inches.
And, yes, they look similar side-by-side, but do an LGF-like comparison, overlaying the two, and you see that they are different.
I took the one from the manual, made the text red, changed the transparency, then overlayed and adjusted the size so it matches. And I've doubled the size so you can see the results:

First off, the line to line height is different, but even if they were the same line height (the Composer was supposedly adjustable), the word spacing would still be different.
Mendelson here has pulled the old, look, I'm at a magazine, I represent the truth, believe what I say trick without realizing we'll check him. Even better, the blogosphere is way ahead of this - Shape of Things has done this already. Answer is, it ain't the same.
And I'm not going to be the only one to address this article, either.
I think Mendelson is about to learn about blogs.
UPDATE: LGF already on it.
posted by blaster at 06:03 PM | Comments (6)
|
 |